このレポートの位置づけ
目的
Report 03 は、前回の変化リスト changed_top1_with_deepseek.csv に含まれる
55件だけを再評価します。このCSVは対象レコードの抽出にだけ使い、
過去の deepseek_label は判定にも集計にも使っていません。
評価対象は query、baseline top-1、improved top-1 の3点です。
- 見るもの: top-1 変更が意味のある改善か、悪化か、実質変化なしか
- 見ないもの: これまでの
changed_top1_with_deepseek.csvの判定 - 参考のみ: 直前の絶対整合性レビューにおける baseline 側ラベル
判定方法
- Pass 1: DeepSeek flash / strict prompt
- Pass 2: DeepSeek flash / specificity-aware prompt
- Pass 3: DeepSeek pro / conservative adjudication prompt
- 最終判定: 3回の多数決、票割れは要目視寄りに扱う
概要
対象件数
55
changed top-1 only
3パス完了
55/55
flash x2 + pro x1
改善
32
58.2%
要確認/悪化系
22
worse + both wrong + uncertain
final_reason は3回分の理由を | で連結しています。
個別理由はCSVの pass1_reason、pass2_reason、pass3_reason に残しています。
改善判定の分布
| ラベル | 件数 | 割合 | 分布 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 改善 | 32 | 58.2% | |
| 両方不整合 | 17 | 30.9% | |
| 悪化 | 5 | 9.1% | |
| 実質変化なし | 1 | 1.8% |
baseline / improved の絶対整合性
baseline
| ラベル | 件数 | 割合 | 分布 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 不整合 | 33 | 60.0% | |
| 上位概念 | 19 | 34.5% | |
| 整合 | 2 | 3.6% | |
| 部分/狭すぎ | 1 | 1.8% |
improved
| ラベル | 件数 | 割合 | 分布 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 不整合 | 19 | 34.5% | |
| 整合 | 17 | 30.9% | |
| 上位概念 | 14 | 25.5% | |
| 部分/狭すぎ | 5 | 9.1% |
整合性ラベルの遷移
| baseline | improved | 件数 |
|---|---|---|
| 不整合 | 不整合 | 17 |
| 不整合 | 整合 | 11 |
| 上位概念 | 上位概念 | 8 |
| 上位概念 | 整合 | 6 |
| 不整合 | 上位概念 | 5 |
| 上位概念 | 部分/狭すぎ | 4 |
| 整合 | 上位概念 | 1 |
| 上位概念 | 不整合 | 1 |
| 部分/狭すぎ | 部分/狭すぎ | 1 |
| 整合 | 不整合 | 1 |
確実性
high
50
final certainty
medium
5
final certainty
low
final certainty
API failures
2
retry log included
| 不確実性タグ | 件数 |
|---|---|
| stable | 50 |
| majority_vote | 4 |
| majority_vote+low_certainty | 1 |
55件詳細
| dataset | query | candidates | consistency | improvement | certainty | reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Centrolateral and paracentral thalamic nuclei |
baseline: rostral intralaminar nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:10443 / score 0.7199 / abs broader_parent
improved: paracentral nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10446 / score 0.6399
|
上位概念 → 部分/狭すぎ | 悪化 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline (rostral intralaminar) correctly contains both centrolateral and paracentral; improved only includes paracentral, missing centrolateral. | Baseline broader_parent (rostral intralaminar includes both nuclei); improved partial (only paracentral). Moving from broader to partial is worse. | Baseline rostral intralaminar correctly encompasses both; improved only provides paracentral, missing centrolateral. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Cuneate Gracile Nuclei |
baseline: sensory relay nuclei in medulla oblongata
HOMBA:12587 / score 0.8052 / abs broader_parent
improved: gracile nucleus
HOMBA:12592 / score 0.7252
|
上位概念 → 部分/狭すぎ | 悪化 | high 3/3 stable |
Query expects both cuneate and gracile nuclei. Baseline broader_parent includes both; improved only gracile nucleus, missing cuneate. | Query is Cuneate+Gracile nuclei. Baseline is broader parent class. Improved only covers gracile, missing cuneate, so partial. | Baseline covers both cuneate and gracile nuclei as a broader class; improved only names gracile nucleus, missing cuneate. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Lateral Dorsal Amygdaloid Nucleus |
baseline: lateral nucleus of amygdala
HOMBA:10367 / score 0.7036 / abs broader_parent
improved: dorsal division of anterior amygdaloid area
HOMBA:146034710 / score 0.5707
|
上位概念 → 不整合 | 悪化 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'lateral nucleus of amygdala' is broader parent; improved 'dorsal division of anterior amygdaloid area' is wrong structure. | Baseline 'lateral nucleus' is parent of lateral dorsal; improved 'dorsal division of anterior amygdaloid area' is a different region. | Query lateral dorsal amygdaloid nucleus; baseline lateral nucleus is anatomically broader parent; improved dorsal division of anterior amygdaloid area is unrelated structure. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Lateral Dorsal Thalamus |
baseline: lateral dorsal nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10396 / score 0.8669 / abs aligned
improved: dorsal thalamus
HOMBA:10391 / score 0.9033
|
整合 → 上位概念 | 悪化 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'lateral dorsal nucleus of thalamus' aligns with query; improved 'dorsal thalamus' is broader, loses lateral specificity. | Query Lateral Dorsal Thalamus. Baseline specific 'lateral dorsal nucleus' (aligned). Improved 'dorsal thalamus' is broader. | Baseline exactly names lateral dorsal nucleus; improved dorsal thalamus is a too-broad parent. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Medial Emminence |
baseline: medial eminence
HOMBA:12820 / score 0.8199 / abs aligned
improved: fastigial (medial) nucleus
HOMBA:12402 / score 0.5
|
整合 → 不整合 | 悪化 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'medial eminence' directly matches query. Improved 'fastigial (medial) nucleus' is a different cerebellar structure. | Baseline 'medial eminence' exactly matches query (typographical variant). Improved 'fastigial nucleus' is cerebellar and anatomically wrong. | Baseline directly matches 'medial eminence'; improved is cerebellar fastigial nucleus, unrelated. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Anterior intraparietal area |
baseline: rostral (anterior) branch of anterior commissure
HOMBA:AA30484 / score 0.5493 / abs
improved: anterior amygdaloid area
HOMBA:10362 / score 0.5068
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Both candidates are anatomically incorrect for anterior intraparietal area. | Both candidates are anatomically wrong: baseline is commissure, improved is amygdala, neither matches parietal intraparietal area. | Anterior intraparietal area is parietal cortex; baseline is commissure branch, improved is amygdala area. Both mismatched. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Anterior ventral insular area |
baseline: anterior (ventral) spinal artery
HOMBA:AA30890 / score 0.7074 / abs wrong
improved: anterior (ventral /principal) pretectal nucleus
HOMBA:12187 / score 0.5
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline is spinal artery, improved is pretectal nucleus. Query is insular area. Both are completely off-structure. | Anterior ventral insular area; baseline (spinal artery) and improved (pretectal nucleus) are not insular. Both wrong. | Anterior ventral insula not matched; spinal artery and pretectal nucleus are different structures. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Central opercular cortex (anterior) |
baseline: lateral (rostral) entorhinal cortex
HOMBA:10318 / score 0.6516 / abs wrong
improved: anterior cingulate cortex (ventromedial prefrontal cortex)
HOMBA:10278 / score 0.5
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline is entorhinal cortex (temporal), improved is cingulate cortex (medial frontal). Neither matches opercular cortex (lateral frontal). Both are anatomically off. | Both candidates are anatomically distinct from central opercular cortex (anterior). Baseline: entorhinal cortex; improved: anterior cingulate. Neither matches. | Query is opercular cortex; both candidates (entorhinal and anterior cingulate) are anatomically unrelated. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Central opercular cortex (posterior) |
baseline: frontal motor cortex (posterior frontal cortex)
HOMBA:AA30009 / score 0.646 / abs wrong
improved: caudal (posterior) branch of anterior commissure
HOMBA:AA30485 / score 0.5
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Both candidates: baseline frontal motor cortex and improved caudal branch of anterior commissure are not opercular cortex; both wrong. | Baseline frontal motor cortex and improved anterior commissure branch are both unrelated to central opercular cortex. | Baseline is frontal motor cortex, improved is a commissure; neither corresponds to the parietal operculum (central opercular cortex). |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Cuneal cortex |
baseline: external shell (cortex) of inferior colliculus
HOMBA:12308 / score 0.5664 / abs wrong
improved: posterior limiting parietal cortex
HOMBA:AA30018 / score 0.5133
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Neither candidate matches cuneal cortex; both are off-lobe. | Cuneal cortex is occipital; baseline is midbrain, improved is parietal cortex. Both incorrect. | Cuneal cortex is occipital; baseline is inferior colliculus cortex, improved is parietal cortex. Both wrong structures. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Intracalcarine cortex (inferior) |
baseline: inferior lateral parietal cortex
HOMBA:10225 / score 0.6815 / abs wrong
improved: caudal (posterior, inferior) medullary velum
HOMBA:12879 / score 0.5
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline is parietal cortex, improved is medullary velum (cerebellar). Intracalcarine cortex is occipital. Both are anatomically wrong. | Intracalcarine cortex (inferior) is occipital; baseline (inferior lateral parietal) and improved (medullary velum) are unrelated. | Inferior lateral parietal and medullary velum are not intracalcarine/inferior calcarine cortex. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Intracalcarine cortex (superior) |
baseline: superior medial parietal cortex
HOMBA:10215 / score 0.6664 / abs wrong
improved: caudal division of area 22
HOMBA:10243 / score 0.5
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline is parietal cortex, improved is area 22 (temporal). Intracalcarine cortex is occipital. Both are wrong. | Intracalcarine cortex (superior) is occipital; baseline (superior medial parietal) and improved (caudal area 22) are in parietal/temporal lobes. | Intracalcarine cortex is calcarine; superior medial parietal and caudal area 22 are not the structure. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Ventral intraparietal area |
baseline: ventral tegmental area
HOMBA:12261 / score 0.6667 / abs wrong
improved: anterior (ventral /principal) pretectal nucleus
HOMBA:12187 / score 0.5
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Both candidates: baseline ventral tegmental area and improved pretectal nucleus are not intraparietal area; both wrong. | Both candidates are non-cortical: VTA (midbrain) and pretectal nucleus, not ventral intraparietal area. | Both candidates are midbrain/subcortical structures, whereas the query is a cortical area in the intraparietal sulcus (parietal lobe). |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Central opercular cortex, posterior |
baseline: frontal motor cortex (posterior frontal cortex)
HOMBA:AA30009 / score 0.646 / abs wrong
improved: lobule III (central lobule and wing, posterior part)
HOMBA:12841 / score 0.5794
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Both candidates are anatomically unrelated to posterior opercular cortex; baseline is frontal motor area, improved is cerebellar lobule. | Both candidates incorrect: baseline is frontal motor cortex not opercular; improved is cerebellar lobule, not cortex. | Both candidates are not in the opercular cortex; baseline is frontal motor, improved is cerebellar lobule III. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Lateral Dorsal Tegmentum |
baseline: lateral cell group of medulla tegmentum
HOMBA:AA30457 / score 0.5697 / abs wrong
improved: dorsal cell group of medulla tegmentum
HOMBA:AA30451 / score 0.5593
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | medium 2/3 majority_vote |
Both candidates are medulla tegmentum cell groups; query 'Lateral Dorsal Tegmentum' likely pons/midbrain, not medulla. | Query 'Lateral Dorsal Tegmentum'. Baseline only 'lateral', improved only 'dorsal' cell group. Both partial; neither fully correct. | Query likely means lateral dorsal tegmental nucleus (pontine); both candidates are medullary tegmentum structures, incorrect. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Laterodorsal thalamic nucleus, ventrolateral part |
baseline: rostral intralaminar nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:10443 / score 0.6508 / abs wrong
improved: laterodorsal tegmental nucleus
HOMBA:12519 / score 0.6365
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Query is thalamic laterodorsal nucleus; baseline is rostral intralaminar, improved is tegmental nucleus; neither matches. | Both wrong: baseline is rostral intralaminar nuclei, not laterodorsal thalamic; improved is tegmental nucleus, not thalamus. | LD thalamic nucleus vs intralaminar nuclei and tegmental nucleus; both anatomically wrong. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Medial Dorsal Tegmentum |
baseline: magnocellular (dorsal) division of BM
HOMBA:11522 / score 0.592 / abs wrong
improved: dorsal cell group of medulla tegmentum
HOMBA:AA30451 / score 0.5542
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | medium 2/3 majority_vote |
Baseline magnocellular BM is unrelated. Improved dorsal medulla tegmentum is not medial dorsal midbrain tegmentum. Both wrong. | Baseline is magnocellular division of BM (basal forebrain). Improved is dorsal cell group of medulla tegmentum, still not medial dorsal tegmentum but at least in tegmentum. | Baseline is forebrain (BM); improved is medullary tegmentum, not typical dorsal tegmental nuclei; neither matches query region. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Paraventricular hypothalamic nucleus |
baseline: dorsal midline nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:AA30274 / score 0.8661 / abs wrong
improved: paraventricular nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10457 / score 0.7861
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Query specifies hypothalamic nucleus; baseline is thalamic midline, improved is thalamic paraventricular. Both wrong region. | Baseline is dorsal midline thalamus (wrong). Improved is paraventricular nucleus of thalamus, not hypothalamic. Both are incorrect for hypothalamic query. | Query is hypothalamic; both candidates are thalamic (wrong region). |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Ventral orbital area |
baseline: ventral tegmental area
HOMBA:12261 / score 0.6981 / abs
improved: anterior (ventral /principal) pretectal nucleus
HOMBA:12187 / score 0.5
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Ventral orbital area is cortical; baseline is VTA, improved is pretectal nucleus; both off-structure. | Both wrong: baseline VTA is midbrain; improved pretectal nucleus is also not orbital cortex. | Ventral orbital area (cortex) vs ventral tegmental area and pretectal nucleus; both off-structure. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Ventroposterior Inferior Thalamus |
baseline: ventral midline nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:AA30276 / score 0.4975 / abs wrong
improved: ventroanterior-ventrolateral nuclear complex of thalamus
HOMBA:AA30289 / score 0.5108
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Neither ventral midline nor ventroanterior-ventrolateral complex match ventroposterior inferior thalamus. | Neither baseline (ventral midline nuclei) nor improved (ventroanterior-ventrolateral complex) matches ventroposterior inferior thalamus. Both wrong. | Query is ventral posterior inferior nucleus; both candidates refer to other thalamic groups. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Ventroposterior Medial and Lateral Thalamus |
baseline: ventral lateral nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10420 / score 0.588 / abs wrong
improved: lateral posterior nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10408 / score 0.6275
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Query targets ventroposterior medial/lateral thalamus; baseline ventral lateral and improved lateral posterior are anatomically incorrect. | Query ventroposterior medial/lateral. Baseline 'ventral lateral' and improved 'lateral posterior' are different structures. | Query refers to ventroposterior complex; baseline is ventral lateral, improved is lateral posterior, both wrong. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Ventroposterior inferior thalamic nucleus |
baseline: pulvinar of thalamus
HOMBA:10409 / score 0.7071 / abs wrong
improved: caudal intralaminar nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:10448 / score 0.663
|
不整合 → 不整合 | 両方不整合 | high 3/3 stable |
Ventroposterior inferior thalamic nucleus; baseline is pulvinar, improved is caudal intralaminar; both different thalamic nuclei. | Both wrong: baseline pulvinar and improved caudal intralaminar are different from ventroposterior inferior thalamic nucleus. | VPI thalamic nucleus vs pulvinar and caudal intralaminar nuclei; both different thalamic groups. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Optic tract/chiasma |
baseline: optic tract
HOMBA:10589 / score 0.7884 / abs partial_or_narrower
improved: optic chiasm
HOMBA:10644 / score 0.7436
|
部分/狭すぎ → 部分/狭すぎ | 実質変化なし | high 3/3 stable |
Query 'optic tract/chiasma' includes both. Baseline 'optic tract' and improved 'optic chiasm' each cover only one part, so both are partial. | Query 'Optic tract/chiasma' includes both; baseline covers tract, improved covers chiasm; both are partial, neither fully covers compound query. | Both candidates match only one component of the compound query (tract vs. chiasm), no clear preference. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Lateral intraparietal area (dorsal) |
baseline: dorsal raphe nucleus, lateral division
HOMBA:12227 / score 0.6014 / abs wrong
improved: lateral subdivision of area 7
HOMBA:267498979 / score 0.5793
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | medium 2/3 majority_vote |
Baseline 'dorsal raphe nucleus' is wrong (brainstem); improved 'lateral subdivision of area 7' correctly matches lateral intraparietal area. | Baseline raphe nucleus is wrong; improved 'lateral subdivision of area 7' is broader but correct cortical region for LIP. | Query is lateral intraparietal area (dorsal) in parietal cortex; baseline dorsal raphe nucleus (brainstem) is wrong; improved lateral subdivision of area 7 is not LIP. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Medial dorsal thalamic nucleus |
baseline: central medial nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10445 / score 0.7753 / abs wrong
improved: mediodorsal nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10398 / score 1.0
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'central medial nucleus' is a different thalamic nucleus. Improved 'mediodorsal nucleus' is a direct synonym for medial dorsal thalamic nucleus. Clear improvement. | Baseline central medial nucleus is a different thalamic nucleus; improved mediodorsal nucleus is the exact match for medial dorsal thalamic nucleus. | Baseline central medial is distinct thalamic nucleus; improved mediodorsal is exact match to Medial dorsal thalamic nucleus. |
| corpus llm_reject_top1 |
Precuneal cortex |
baseline: prefrontal cortex
HOMBA:10172 / score 0.5343 / abs wrong
improved: cerebral cortex
HOMBA:10159 / score 0.5
|
不整合 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline prefrontal cortex is wrong; improved cerebral cortex is a broader parent including precuneal. | Baseline prefrontal cortex is wrong (frontal lobe). Improved cerebral cortex is a valid broad parent, moving from wrong to acceptable. | Precuneal cortex is parietal; baseline prefrontal is wrong. Improved 'cerebral cortex' is correct parent structure (broader). |
| corpus llm_accept_top1 |
Secondary visual cortex |
baseline: dorsolateral extrastriate occipital cortex
HOMBA:AA30822 / score 0.8347 / abs ambiguous
improved: dorsal secondary visual cortex (dorsal area 18, dorsal area OB, area 18a)
HOMBA:AA30823 / score 0.7547
|
上位概念 → 部分/狭すぎ | 改善 | medium 2/3 majority_vote |
Improved directly names secondary visual cortex; baseline is broader extrastriate cortex. | Baseline 'dorsolateral extrastriate occipital cortex' is broader (includes secondary visual cortex). Improved 'dorsal secondary visual cortex' is a specific part, thus partial/narrower. Improved is more specific and closer to the query than the broad parent, an improvement. | Baseline is ambiguous (dorsolateral extrastriate occipital cortex could be broader or partial). Improved is dorsal secondary visual cortex, partial/narrower than the query. Both miss the full secondary visual cortex. |
| corpus llm_accept_top1 |
Superior parietal gyrus |
baseline: parietal lobe
HOMBA:12131 / score 0.8771 / abs broader_parent
improved: superior parietal lobule (gyrus)
HOMBA:12133 / score 0.7971
|
上位概念 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Improved is exact match for superior parietal gyrus; baseline is broader parietal lobe. | Baseline 'parietal lobe' is a broader parent. Improved 'superior parietal lobule (gyrus)' exactly matches the query 'Superior parietal gyrus'. Clear improvement. | Improved candidate (superior parietal lobule/gyrus) directly matches the query, while baseline (parietal lobe) is too broad. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Abducens Motor Nucleus |
baseline: efferent nuclei of cranial nerves in pons
HOMBA:12417 / score 0.8193 / abs broader_parent
improved: abducens nucleus
HOMBA:12418 / score 0.7393
|
上位概念 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline broader grouping of cranial nerve nuclei; improved abducens nucleus directly matches query. | Baseline 'efferent nuclei of cranial nerves in pons' is broader; improved 'abducens nucleus' is the exact anatomical structure. | Baseline 'efferent nuclei...' is a broader category; improved 'abducens nucleus' is the exact queried structure. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Anterior pituitary |
baseline: pituitary body/gland (hypophysis)
HOMBA:10505 / score 0.7081 / abs broader_parent
improved: anterior lobe of pituitary body (adenohypophysis)
HOMBA:AA30782 / score 0.6281
|
上位概念 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Improved directly matches anterior pituitary; baseline is whole pituitary gland. | Baseline 'pituitary body/gland' is a broader parent. Improved 'anterior lobe of pituitary body (adenohypophysis)' exactly matches 'Anterior pituitary'. Clear improvement. | Improved (anterior lobe/adenohypophysis) is the exact match; baseline (pituitary gland) is the whole organ. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Basolateral Intermediate Amygdaloid Nucleus |
baseline: basolateral nuclear group of amygdala
HOMBA:10366 / score 0.7408 / abs broader_parent
improved: basolateral nucleus (basal nucleus) of amygdala
HOMBA:10368 / score 0.6608
|
上位概念 → 部分/狭すぎ | 改善 | medium 3/3 majority_vote+low_certainty |
Improved is specific basolateral nucleus but lacks 'intermediate'; baseline broader group. | Baseline is the parent nuclear group; improved is the specific basolateral nucleus, better matching query's 'intermediate' amygdala nucleus. | Query expects a subnucleus; baseline is nuclear group, improved is basolateral nucleus, which is closer but still broader than the intermediate subnucleus. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Basomedial amygdaloid nucleus |
baseline: basolateral nuclear group of amygdala
HOMBA:10366 / score 0.7072 / abs broader_parent
improved: basomedial nucleus (accessory basal nucleus) of amygdala
HOMBA:10369 / score 0.6272
|
上位概念 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'basolateral nuclear group' is broader; improved 'basomedial nucleus' matches query exactly. | Baseline basolateral group is broader parent; improved basomedial nucleus directly matches query. | Improved is the basomedial nucleus; baseline is basolateral group, which is wrong. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 1 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs wrong
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
不整合 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is wrong for cerebellar lobule 1 vermis. Improved 'cerebellar vermis' is parent, much closer. | Query 'Cerebellar Lobule 1 Vermis' specific; baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is wrong, improved 'cerebellar vermis' is correct parent. | Baseline is generic morphology; improved is the vermis, the correct parent of lobule 1. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 10 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7921 / abs wrong
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7121
|
不整合 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is too broad/wrong for cerebellar lobule 10 vermis. Improved 'cerebellar vermis' is the parent, clearly better. | Query 'Cerebellar Lobule 10 Vermis' specific; baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is too general, improved 'cerebellar vermis' is correct parent. | Baseline is generic morphology; improved is the vermis, which is the correct parent structure of lobule 10. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 2 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs wrong
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
不整合 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is wrong for cerebellar lobule 2 vermis. Improved 'cerebellar vermis' is parent, clearly better. | Query 'Cerebellar Lobule 2 Vermis' specific; baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is wrong, improved 'cerebellar vermis' is correct parent. | Baseline is generic morphology; improved is the vermis, the correct parent of lobule 2. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 3 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs broader_parent
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
上位概念 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is a very broad term; improved 'cerebellar vermis' is more specific to the vermis region, directly matching part of query, but still broader than specific lobule vermis. | Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is very broad; improved 'cerebellar vermis' is the correct parent region for the lobule query, though still broader than the specific lobule. | Improved term 'cerebellar vermis' is a more specific parent than baseline 'cerebellar morphology', but still broader than the queried lobule. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 4 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs broader_parent
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
上位概念 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Same pattern as record 40. Improved candidate is more specific to vermis, a closer match to query than broad 'cerebellar morphology'. | Same as record 40; improved vermis term is a closer anatomical match than morphology. | Improved term 'cerebellar vermis' is a more specific parent than baseline 'cerebellar morphology', but still broader than the queried lobule. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 5 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs broader_parent
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
上位概念 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Same pattern as record 40. Improved candidate is more specific to vermis, a closer match to query than broad 'cerebellar morphology'. | Same pattern; improved candidate correctly targets the vermis region. | Improved term 'cerebellar vermis' is a more specific parent than baseline 'cerebellar morphology', but still broader than the queried lobule. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 6 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs broader_parent
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
上位概念 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Same pattern as record 40. Improved candidate is more specific to vermis, a closer match to query than broad 'cerebellar morphology'. | Improved term is more specific to the anatomical site compared to the generic morphology term. | Improved term 'cerebellar vermis' is a more specific parent than baseline 'cerebellar morphology', but still broader than the queried lobule. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 7 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs broader_parent
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
上位概念 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Same pattern as record 40. Improved candidate is more specific to vermis, a closer match to query than broad 'cerebellar morphology'. | Improved candidate 'cerebellar vermis' is a meaningful step toward the correct structure. | Improved term 'cerebellar vermis' is a more specific parent than baseline 'cerebellar morphology', but still broader than the queried lobule. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 8 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs broader_parent
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
上位概念 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is a broad concept; improved 'cerebellar vermis' is closer but still broader than query 'Cerebellar Lobule 8 Vermis'. | Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is not an anatomical part; improved 'cerebellar vermis' is the correct broader parent of lobule 8 vermis. | Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is too broad; improved 'cerebellar vermis' is a more specific parent of Lobule 8 Vermis, closer to the query. |
| species llm_out_of_scope_for_rcs |
Cerebellar Lobule 9 Vermis |
baseline: cerebellar morphology
HOMBA:AA30563 / score 0.7986 / abs broader_parent
improved: cerebellar vermis
HOMBA:10658 / score 0.7186
|
上位概念 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline is broad morphology; improved cerebellar vermis is more specific but still broader than lobule 9 vermis. | Baseline 'cerebellar morphology' is wrong; improved 'cerebellar vermis' is the broader parent of lobule 9 vermis. | Similar to record 45: improved vermis is a more precise broader parent than general cerebellar morphology. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Dorsal Lateral Leminscus Nucleus |
baseline: lateral geniculate nucleus (dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus)
HOMBA:10429 / score 0.811 / abs wrong
improved: dorsal nucleus of lateral lemniscus
HOMBA:12455 / score 0.9726
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline lateral geniculate is wrong; improved dorsal nucleus of lateral lemniscus exactly matches query. | Baseline 'lateral geniculate nucleus' is wrong; improved 'dorsal nucleus of lateral lemniscus' exactly matches the query. | Baseline lateral geniculate is visual thalamic, unrelated; improved dorsal nucleus of lateral lemniscus matches the query exactly. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Frontal orbital cortex, anterior |
baseline: frontal cortex
HOMBA:10161 / score 0.7983 / abs broader_parent
improved: orbital frontal cortex
HOMBA:10194 / score 0.7184
|
上位概念 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Improved orbital frontal cortex is closer than frontal cortex, but missing 'anterior'. | Baseline 'frontal cortex' is too broad; improved 'orbital frontal cortex' is a more specific region, but still lacks 'anterior' granularity. | Improved (orbital frontal cortex) is a more specific parent region than the baseline's frontal cortex, though both miss the 'anterior' qualifier. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Interanteromedial Thalamus |
baseline: ventral midline nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:AA30276 / score 0.7068 / abs wrong
improved: interanteromedial nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:13048 / score 0.6268
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'ventral midline nuclei' is a broader group; improved 'interanteromedial nucleus' is exact match to query. | Baseline ventral midline nuclei is not the correct structure; improved interanteromedial nucleus exactly matches query. | Improved matches query exactly; baseline is a different structure (ventral midline). |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Intermediodorsal Thalamus |
baseline: dorsal midline nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:AA30274 / score 0.7102 / abs broader_parent
improved: intermediodorsal nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:13049 / score 0.6302
|
上位概念 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'dorsal midline nuclei' is broader; improved 'intermediodorsal nucleus' is exact match. | Baseline dorsal midline nuclei is broader parent; improved intermediodorsal nucleus exactly matches query. | Improved is the specific nucleus; baseline is a broader parent group. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Laterodorsal thalamic nucleus |
baseline: anterodorsal nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10393 / score 0.7847 / abs wrong
improved: lateral dorsal nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10396 / score 1.0
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'anterodorsal nucleus' is wrong; improved 'lateral dorsal nucleus' matches query. | Baseline anterodorsal nucleus is wrong; improved lateral dorsal nucleus exactly matches query. | Improved is lateral dorsal nucleus (laterodorsal); baseline is anterodorsal, different nucleus. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Medial Raphe |
baseline: fastigial (medial) nucleus
HOMBA:12402 / score 0.8075 / abs wrong
improved: median raphe nucleus
HOMBA:12235 / score 0.5491
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline fastigial nucleus is anatomically wrong; improved median raphe nucleus matches query 'Medial Raphe'. | Baseline 'fastigial (medial) nucleus' is incorrect; improved 'median raphe nucleus' is a direct match for query 'Medial Raphe'. | Baseline fastigial nucleus is cerebellar, wrong; improved median raphe nucleus matches Medial Raphe query. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Orbital cortex (ventral) |
baseline: anterior (ventral /principal) pretectal nucleus
HOMBA:12187 / score 0.6295 / abs wrong
improved: orbital frontal cortex
HOMBA:10194 / score 0.6158
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline is wrong; improved orbital frontal cortex is synonymous with orbital cortex. | Baseline pretectal nucleus is wrong. Improved orbital frontal cortex is correct for orbital cortex ventral. | Orbital cortex (ventral) is orbitofrontal; baseline pretectal wrong, improved 'orbital frontal cortex' direct match. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Spinal Trigeminal Nucleus Intermediate |
baseline: afferent nuclei of cranial nerves in pons
HOMBA:12436 / score 0.7809 / abs wrong
improved: spinal trigeminal nucleus
HOMBA:12572 / score 0.7547
|
不整合 → 上位概念 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'afferent nuclei of cranial nerves in pons' is wrong for spinal trigeminal nucleus intermediate. Improved 'spinal trigeminal nucleus' is the broader parent, much closer. | Query specifies 'Spinal Trigeminal Nucleus Intermediate'; baseline is a pons nuclei grouping (wrong), improved is the correct parent nucleus. | Baseline is a different grouping of nuclei; improved is the correct parent nucleus of the queried intermediate part. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Ventral striatal region, unspecified |
baseline: anterior (ventral /principal) pretectal nucleus
HOMBA:12187 / score 0.6019 / abs wrong
improved: ventral striatum (STRv)
HOMBA:AA30195 / score 0.5681
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline is wrong (pretectal nucleus); improved ventral striatum directly matches query. | Baseline pretectal nucleus is wrong. Improved ventral striatum directly matches query. | Ventral striatal region matched by improved 'ventral striatum'; baseline pretectal nucleus is wrong. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Ventrolateral thalamic nucleus |
baseline: rostral intralaminar nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:10443 / score 0.7446 / abs wrong
improved: ventral lateral nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10420 / score 1.0
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'rostral intralaminar nuclei' is wrong; improved 'ventral lateral nucleus' matches query. | Baseline rostral intralaminar nuclei is wrong; improved ventral lateral nucleus exactly matches query. | Improved is ventral lateral nucleus (synonym); baseline is rostral intralaminar, unrelated. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Ventromedial occipital cortex |
baseline: extrastriate occipital cortex
HOMBA:10270 / score 0.8636 / abs broader_parent
improved: ventromedial extrastriate occipital cortex
HOMBA:AA30826 / score 0.7836
|
上位概念 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Improved 'ventromedial extrastriate occipital cortex' matches query exactly; baseline is broader extrastriate. | Query ventromedial occipital cortex. Baseline broader extrastriate occipital cortex. Improved exactly matches query. | Baseline extrastriate is a broader parent; improved adds ventromedial specificity, directly matching the query. |
| species llm_reject_top1 |
Ventromedial thalamic nucleus |
baseline: caudal intralaminar nuclei of thalamus
HOMBA:10448 / score 0.8387 / abs wrong
improved: ventral medial nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10427 / score 1.0
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'caudal intralaminar nuclei' is wrong. Improved 'ventral medial nucleus of thalamus' is a synonym for ventromedial thalamic nucleus. | Baseline is caudal intralaminar nuclei (wrong). Improved 'ventral medial nucleus of thalamus' is a standard synonym for ventromedial thalamic nucleus. | Improved 'ventral medial nucleus' is synonymous with query; baseline is intralaminar nuclei. |
| species llm_accept_top1 |
Ventromedial thalamic nucleus (posterior and basal) |
baseline: posterior nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10440 / score 0.7021 / abs
improved: ventral medial nucleus of thalamus
HOMBA:10427 / score 0.88
|
不整合 → 整合 | 改善 | high 3/3 stable |
Baseline 'posterior nucleus of thalamus' is different nucleus; improved 'ventral medial nucleus of thalamus' is direct synonym for ventromedial nucleus. | Baseline 'posterior nucleus' is incorrect; improved 'ventral medial nucleus' is exact match for ventromedial thalamic nucleus. | Query is ventromedial thalamic nucleus; baseline posterior nucleus is a different thalamic nucleus; improved ventral medial nucleus is exact match. |